JOIN THE ICON SOCIETY
Earn points for orders, reviews and more — plus a birthday surprise each year. Redeem your points for Everly gift cards or jewelry.





track your progress in cart!
track your progress and earn free rewards in cart
plus a free sticker pack with every order
The finishing touch
Preserve the shine
PROP 65 WARNING: This product can expose you to chemicals including diethanolamine, which is known to the State of California to cause cancer www.P65warnings.ca.gov.
a little mystery, a little sparkle! add a surprise to your jewelry collection with our Mystery Charm.
for just $5, you'll receive one mystery charm valued at $20–$25. each charm is randomly selected from our collection, so you never know which little favorite you'll unwrap!
add one to your cart (or a few!) and see what surprise is waiting for you.
details:
please note: all Mystery Charms are final sale. no returns, exchanges, or refunds. specific styles and metals cannot be requested or guaranteed.
14k gold filled: high quality look of gold at a fraction of the price of solid gold. a thick layer of 14k gold heat & pressure bonded to brass. tarnish resistant & contains much more gold than gold plating.
925 sterling silver: solid, precious metal that lasts. darkens over time but can easily be polished up.
18k gold vermeil: made with a thick layer of 18k gold over solid sterling silver for a rich, long-lasting finish. offers the look and feel of solid gold with better durability than standard gold plating.
18k gold plated: we use a thick plating of 18k gold over a brass base.
rhodium plated: rhodium plating is slightly darker silver color than our sterling silver option. rhodium itself doesn’t easily oxidize, corrode or react to your skin. it’s nickel-free and naturally hypoallergenic.
free standard shipping on us orders $75+.
click here to view our full return/exchange policy.
Choose options





Earn points for orders, reviews and more — plus a birthday surprise each year. Redeem your points for Everly gift cards or jewelry.